Some of the people who use the same leg press as you every week will never once be in the building at the same time as you. The 6 AM regulars and the 7 PM regulars know each other only by the seat height left behind, which is a strangely intimate thing to know about a stranger. Both shifts are sure they picked the better hour, and since they never overlap long enough to argue about it, we went looking for a referee.
In a 12-week study, researchers had fit adults in their 40s follow the same training program either between 6 and 8 in the morning or between 6:30 and 8:30 at night, eating about the same food either way. If you were hoping for a clear winner, you'll have to settle for a split check. The women who trained in the morning lost more belly fat and saw a bigger drop in blood pressure, while the women who trained at night gained more upper-body strength and power. Among the men, the evening group got the bigger blood pressure drop and also reported feeling less tired, an outcome suggesting that none of them has a toddler.
The split check
- Morning (6 to 8 AM), women: more belly fat lost and a bigger blood pressure drop
- Evening (6:30 to 8:30 PM), women: more upper-body strength and power
- Evening (6:30 to 8:30 PM), men: a bigger blood pressure drop, and they felt less tired
The groups were small and everyone in them already exercised regularly, so it works better as a tiebreaker than a verdict. That still leaves the morning crowd free to keep their 5:30 alarms and everyone else free to hit snooze with a clear conscience.
What the clock does to your lifts
If you've ever tried to open a jar before coffee, you already know most people are a bit stronger in the evening than first thing in the morning. A review pooling 11 studies saw that same dip at the start, and then watched it shrink in the people who trained early. Lifting in the morning made people better at lifting in the morning specifically, so by the end, their morning strength had nearly caught up to what evening lifters could do after work. The evening lifters stayed strongest in the evening, and when researchers compared how much each group improved overall, both had gained about the same amount of strength and muscle. So the time you train changes when in the day you feel strongest, and barely touches how much stronger you get.
If your calendar only has room for 6 AM, you'll get strong at 6 AM, which is very convenient for those planning to move a couch before breakfast.
For the after-dark crowd
Now that it's dark before most of us leave work, the evening workout takes the same leap of faith as the 6 AM one, and the excuse people might lean into is that working out late will keep them up at night. A review of 23 studies looked at exactly that worry and found evening exercise didn't hurt sleep, with people getting slightly more deep sleep on the nights they'd worked out. The one exception was hard, vigorous exercise wrapping up within an hour of bedtime. So if the plan is sprint intervals at 9:45 and lights out at 10:15, expect the first part of the night to involve a lot of staring at the ceiling. Anything earlier, or anything gentler, is fair game.
Put it to work
Whatever hour you've claimed, our personal trainers can build a program around it, so the plan fits the life you already have instead of the one you'd have if you were a morning person. Stop by the front desk to book a session.
See you at whatever o'clock,
Your West Coast Fitness Family
P.S. Erika and Autumn's Strength, Movement & Menopause workshop is Saturday, November 21, from 2 to 6 PM. Spots are $60, and for anyone in the 6 AM crowd, a 2 PM start is practically sleeping in.