Half the cardio. Same heart.
For decades, the deal with heart health was simple and a little joyless: do cardio, the more the better, and if you don't enjoy it, that's between you and God. Strength training was treated like a vanity project, fine for looking good at a wedding but not something a cardiologist would ever bring up. A year-long trial looked at that assumption and found it was mostly nonsense, which is a relief for everyone who has ever stared at the mile counter on a treadmill and felt time itself slow down.
At a glance: 406 adults · 1 year · 3 days a week · 60 minutes a session
Half and half, same payoff
In the CardioRACE trial in the European Heart Journal, researchers took 406 adults with higher body weight and elevated blood pressure and sorted them into four groups for a full year: do nothing, do cardio, do strength, or do a 50/50 split. Everyone exercising put in the same hour, three days a week, with supervision, so nobody could claim they "basically did an hour" while actually doing twenty-two minutes of trying out Instagram filters.
The split group, with 30 minutes of cardio and 30 of lifting, improved their cardiovascular risk as much as the people who spent the whole hour on cardio. Same heart payoff, half the cardio, and they got stronger as a bonus. You are, in effect, being told you can do less of the thing you like least and lose nothing for it, which is the sort of sentence that normally precedes a scam. This one's just true.
You can do less of the thing you like least and lose nothing for it.
But what happened to the lifters?
Then there's the strength-only group, which a lot of us will relate to. They got leaner and stronger over the year, real and enviable results, but their composite heart-risk score barely moved compared to the people who did absolutely nothing. A depressing blow, until you look at why.
That risk score was built from four numbers: blood pressure, LDL cholesterol, blood sugar, and body fat. The lifters did trim body fat, but the score had no column for the muscle and strength they were piling on. When the researchers widened it to count fitness and strength too, the lifting group's score improved right alongside everyone else's. They showed up to a math test having studied history. Still smarter, wrong exam.
The year-end scorecard, compared with no exercise
- Cardio only: heart risk score, cardio fitness and body fat improved; strength showed no clear change
- Strength only: strength and body fat improved; heart risk score and cardio fitness showed no clear change
- Half and half: heart risk score, cardio fitness, strength and body fat all improved
These were adults carrying extra weight with elevated blood pressure, the exact crowd these numbers are built for. The moral of the story still resounds, though: half of your cardio can become strength work and your heart still ends the year exactly where it would have otherwise.
It rhymes with that running thing
A few weeks ago, in the piece about running and your knees, the moral was that spreading your effort across different activities beats marrying one of them. This is the same idea wearing a lab coat: the people who did two things got the heart protection of cardio and the muscle that cardio never hands out. Nobody's making you pick a personality. The whole floor is open.
What to actually do with your hour
If you've been grinding out cardio you don't enjoy because you thought it was the only thing keeping your heart in business, you've been tricked. Trade a cardio day, or half of each session, for the machines, the free weights, the turf, a class, whatever doesn't make you miserable. You keep the heart benefit and collect strength that makes stairs, groceries, and getting off the floor dramatically less dramatic. We mentioned a sliver of this during Heart Month in February, but it deserved the director's cut: your hour was always more flexible than anyone let on.
Strength and cardio fitness? You really can have it all 😉
Keeping your whole self running smoothly,
Your West Coast Fitness Family
P.S. If you think cardio is evil, now you know you can do less of it and still get all the benefits 👺